Evaluation of the differences in length at catch between treatment-control pairs was facilitated using a generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) approach (Zuur and Ieno, 2016). There was strong evidence (Smith, 2020; Muff et al., 2021) that the CPUE of lobsters in the windfarm and associated control site differed between survey years, however there was little to no evidence of CPUE differing between the windfarm and associated control site within each survey year (Figure 4,Table 4). As a Assistant Accountant at G-tec, you will play a vital role in supporting the finance department in maintaining accurate financial records and ensuring compliance with relevant regulations. The top of the bar represents the mean CPUE/LPUE and the top of the error bars represent the 95% confidence intervals of the data. BAG designs, Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, Lobster and cod benefit from small-scale northern marine protected areas: inference from an empirical before-after control-impact study, Proceedings. Over the six-year study (four sampling years), a total of 81 survey days were completed, hauling 9715 pots, recording 28196 lobsters across the four survey sites (Table 1). At Westermost Rough DEME set a new reference in that no onshore storage or marshalling was needed, and the foundations were immediately installed after transport from Aalborg, Denmark. Offshore construction works for the wind farm began in January 2014 with the installation of monopile foundations for the turbines. GLMM parameters for the comparison between the wind farm and export cable and their associated control sites for the pre-construction year (2013) and the 5 years post-build year (2019). The farm covers an area of approximately 35 km 2 (14 sq mi) with a generation capacity of approximately 210 MW. Since 2004 we have been developing, constructing and operating offshore wind farms in the UK - our biggest market. The vertical dashed line represents the minimum landing size for lobsters at the survey sites of 87mm carapace length. When was the first power of Westermost Rough Wind Farm? The GLMM approach described above was also applied separately to ovigerous lobsters, but no trends were observed. This deterrence from an OWF can act as a quasi no-take zone (NTZ) or protected area (Ashley et al., 2014), some ecological benefits associated with OWF have been attributed to this effect (Bergman et al., 2014; Coates et al., 2016; Roach et al., 2018) Potting fisheries which target crustaceans, and aquaculture are the main sectors identified when considering the possibility of co-existence between OWF and fisheries (Hooper and Austen, 2014; Stelzenmller et al., 2016; Rckmann et al., 2017; Kamermans et al., 2018; Sas et al., 2018). In all cases there was no significant difference among the linear, cubic, and quadratic models generated using GLMM (ANOVA, P >0.05 in all models) and the AIC was lowest for the simplest models (i.e. However, this study did not focus on settlement specifically as an objective but focused on changes in the length frequency distribution and catch rates of lobsters below the minimum landing size (MLS) as a proxy for changes in pre-recruitment. This indicates that within all sites sampled, a commercial fisher would experience high levels of discards for lobsters. [35], In May 2015, Ofgem awarded preferred bidder status to own and operate the electrical transmission assets of the wind farm to Transmission Capital Partners;[36] in early 2016 the sale of the assets (TC Westernmost Rough OFTO Ltd.) to a consortium of Transmission Capital Partners Limited Partnership and International Public Partnerships Limited was completed. Site locations were chosen using the fishing industries local ecological knowledge, considering species distribution, catch dynamics, habitat type, water depth, and distance from shore and also the considerations required by the developer to meet their licensing requirements and the proposed construction plans. The spatial scale and generating power of OWF vary widely, ranging from 5 turbines (US: Block Island, 30 MW, 15 km2 footprint to the recently completed Hornsea 1 development (UK, 174 turbines, 1.2 GW, 407 km2 footprint (ten Brink and Dalton, 2018; Orsted, 2020). This was a collaborative study between the Holderness Fishing Industry Group (www.hfig.org.uk) and rsted (WMR developer) with additional support from independent scientific consultants. All animals were returned to the sea immediately post processing. DEME is a leading contractor in the fields of dredging and marine infrastructure. The 210MW Westermost Rough offshore wind farm is located 8km from the Holderness coast in Yorkshire, UK. [26][27], GeoSea was awarded the contract to install foundation piles in April 2013. The study used a fishing industry owned and operated research vessel and fishing industry employees to conduct the study. The return a fisher would expect from the lobsters sampled in this study, defined as landing per unit of effort (LPUE) and based on size and quality of the animal, was considerably lower than the CPUE observed. Whilst CPUE in the windfarm has increased since the pre-construction survey in 2013, this increase has not been consistent, with the lowest CPUE in the windfarm observed in 2017, increasing to the greatest CPUE in 2019. Benthic and fish aggregation inside an offshore wind farm: which effects on the trophic web functioning? 0000000016 00000 n CPUE of lobsters was greatest at all sites in 2019 compared to previous survey years. The voltage is stepped up from low-voltage to high-voltage at the substation. The home range of a lobster can be several kilometres a year (Smith et al., 2001; Agnalt et al., 2007) and this range can increase greatly in the summer months (Moland et al., 2011a) however this may be reduced in the presence of wind turbines (Thatcher, pers. rsted is the largest offshore wind developer in both the world and the UK. The Westermost Rough offshore wind farm was officially inaugurated in July 2015. Credit: Siemens. Consisting of 35 Siemens wind turbines, each with a capacity of 6 megawatts and a rotor diameter of 154 meters, this project is the first to use these turbines on a large scale in a commercial project. Westermost Rough visible on the horizon, under construction in March 2015. As the offshore wind industry expands and technology advances, cooperation between the two industries will be essential for co-existence. The central horizontal line represents the 0.5 (50%) value, data overlapping this line indicates that there was no significant difference in the proportion of an animal of that size between the two sites. soft shelled). windfarm or export cable) and an associated control (Pettersen et al., 2009; Smith, 2014; Franco et al., 2015). There was also a reduced proportion of lobsters across all size ranges, observed at the export cable and control sites in 2019 than previous years. If you are a driven individual with a passion for numbers and a desire to grow your career in accounting, G-tec offers a dynamic and supportive work environment where you can develop your skills and contribute to the success of our organization. The project scale reached 35 square kilometers, roughly 1,000 meters between each turbine installation. Understanding the effects of OWF on commercially important crustacean species can be integral in both future sustainability of the fishery and potential of co-existence between the two industries. Results of type III sum of squares, two-way ANOVA testing CPUE and LPUE between site (wind farm and control) and year (2013/15/17 & 19) for lobsters caught during the WMR survey. However, translating these results to other sites, fishery types and alternative lobster populations should consider the differences in ecology of the affected population and the habitat the development is proposed for, ensuring that discard survival and fisher effects are not compounded by extensive changes to the habitat. [3], A planning application was submitted in November 2009,[4] and consent was given by the Department of Energy and Climate Change in 2011 for a development of up to 80 turbines of up to 245MW power with a limit of 172m (564ft) turbine tip height, and 150m (490ft) rotor diameter, as well as associated onshore and offshore substations, cabling and other infrastructure. A pre-construction survey was undertaken in 2013 and subsequent post-construction surveys in 2015, 2017, and 2019 (Table 1). At different scales and resolutions this could highlight effects that were not captured within this study (i.e. A GLMM was applied in which the relative catch probability of the lobsters at each size (1mm increments) entering the string of pots at each site was the response variable and the carapace length (length) of the lobster was the fixed effect. Humber Gateway is to the south, & Westermost Rough is the square with some turbines missing from the centre. This collaborative study and subsequent development of transparency between the fishing industry and developer, has aided in moving the two industries towards a model of co-existence that can be emulated in other development interactions. Credit: Siemens. Data may be shared on request to the corresponding author with permission of rsted. Onshore construction works began in April 2013 with the construction of underground cables. 0000012775 00000 n to mobile gear types) or the perceived risk for fishers being too high to operate in the site (Hooper et al., 2015; Haggett et al., 2020). If an internal link led you here, you may wish to change the link to point directly to the intended article. Extensive preparation and engineering included the design and fabrication of a state-of-the-art gripper and lifting tools were necessary to achieve successful operations. A single baseline survey was conducted prior to construction, additional baseline surveys would better capture the conditions of the lobster population prior to construction. This follows similar techniques described by (Holst and Revill, 2009; Van Marlen et al., 2014; Vogel et al., 2017; Petetta et al., 2020) analysing catch comparisons between experimental factors. Project developers added additional protection to mitigate the degradation of the array cables in 2021. Westermost Rough is rsteds third largest wind farm and on the east coast of England. As the main contractor for the foundations, DEMEwas responsible for load-out of foundations in Denmark, transportation to the UK, installation and grouting of the monopiles and transition pieces, and secondary works. The Westermost Rough offshore wind farm is located in the UK North Sea, approximately 8km off the East coast of Yorkshire near Withernsea, Yorkshire. In this example, it appears any benefits associated with the addition of hard substrate in the form of scour stone (Krone et al., 2017; Glarou et al., 2020) has not increased the size and catch rates of the lobster in the array area. The turbine installation was completed in March 2015. Watch on Transfer from Siemens SWT-6.0-154 Wind Turbine at the DONG Energy Westermost Rough Project. The surveys were conducted over the summer months (JuneSeptember, inclusive) which matched the main lobster fishing season in the proposed area. In the UK there are currently 38 offshore windfarms (OWF) operational, totalling 2190 turbines with a further 9 sites under construction or in development. During operational phase of UK OWF, safety zones around each turbine will also limit access to fisheries (Dong Energy Ltd, 2009; Hooper et al., 2015). Transition pieces weigh around 367 tonnes each. The frequency of v-notched lobsters, therefore, includes individuals previously caught in this study or released by a commercial fisher. The export cable and associated control sites were outside the closure area of the main array. A. Raoux A., Tecchio S., Pezy J. P., Lassalle G., Degraer S., Wilhelmsson D., Cachera M. et al. *Facts about Altamont wind farm:- Altamont Pass is still the largest concentration of wind turbines in the world, with a capacity of 576 megawatts (MW), prod. \Pr \left\{ {\frac{{Test}}{{Test\ + \ Control}}} \right\} = 1/(1 + {e^{--({\rm{haul}} + {{\rm{\beta }}_1} \times {\rm{length}} + {{\rm{\beta }}_2})}}) This is more likely to be attributed to the introduction of a ban on landing ovigerous lobsters introduced in England 2017 (DEFRA, 2017) which impacted all English lobster fisheries (English landings reduced by 22.5% between 2017 and 2018 (MMO, 2019)) rather than the construction and operation of the Westermost Rough OWF and expansion of offshore wind projects and other marine developments. In each of the four sites surveyed, the size distribution of lobsters changed over the study period, this may have been influenced by unavoidable changes in specific site location between sampling seasons. Credit: Siemens. Biological sciences /The Royal Society, Rewriting results sections in the language of evidence, North Eastern Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authority. Each monopile weighs up to 800t and has a diameter of 6.5m. The expected increase in LPUE at the export cable site (as observed in the windfarm) was not realised. The Crown Estates lease for 240 million is split by 50:25:25 equity participation in the project. Offshore wind farm Developer: Orsted Operator: Orsted Owners: / / Source: Production forecast From Tuesday, July 4 2023, 02:00 UTC, for the coming 24 hours: Expected load rate: 47.1 % Expected production: 2,372,220 kWh Values from Weathernews Windcaster solution Localisation Latitude: 53 48' 17.9" Longitude: 0 8' 56.3" Depth: -15 m A. M., vanOs-Koomen E., vanBarneveld E. Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. Whilst the control sites are only 1km from the treatments, preliminary results from tracking studies undertaken over 3 months in summer 2021 in a wind farm in north Wales show that the majority of lobsters show strong fidelity to turbine bases, although some individuals may move longer distances (3km) (Thatcher, pers. The site is located within one of the fisheries main target areas for lobster during the summer period. Based on the average 874 GWh of the farm, a raw estimate for each turbine is that each turbine produces 24 GWh per year. The global expansion of offshore windfarms (OWF), whilst seen as a tool to combat climate change, can often be of concern to fishing communities already challenged by spatial restrictions. (2015). Since the inauguration of Westermost Rough wind farm in 2015 rsted has been working closely. Additionally the proximity of the control sites may negate detecting smaller signals associated with the catch rates in either the windfarm or export cable due to the home range of a lobster potentially overlapping between the sites (Smith et al., 2001; Agnalt et al., 2007; Moland et al., 2011b). The authors have no conflict of interest to declare. Browse 13 WESTERMOST ROUGH WIND FARM photos and images available, or start a new search to explore more photos and images. The fishery targets lobsters using baited, static pots which are immersed for varying periods from 12 h to several days, fisher and season dependent. In August 2014, the first turbine was erected and first power was generated in September 2014. The rsted Grimsby maintenance base then expanded in 2019 to accommodate theoperationsand maintenance of rsteds wind farms. The facility will last until 2040, or 25 years. The same was observed for the GLMM comparison for the final year post-construction survey in 2019, following a similar trend to the 2013 survey, demonstrating no discernible differences across the size range between the windfarm and control site (Figure 3,Table 3). A2Sea installed the wind turbines using its purpose-built offshore installation vessel Sea Challenger. The size distribution of lobsters sampled at the windfarm and export cable and their associated control sites has shifted over the period of the study. The presence or absence of a v-notch in a caught lobster was recorded in later surveys (2017 and 2019), however, these data can be used as a proxy for recapture rates, with the caveat that lobsters are also v-notched by the wider industry. Analysis was conducted on the differences in the size structure of lobsters between the windfarm site and associated control and also between the export cable and associated control for both the pre-construction survey in 2013 and the 4 years post-construction survey in 2019. Size structure and catch rates differed between years, however differences were not observed in comparisons of the windfarm and export cable to their associated control sites within each year, although there were compounding factors associated with the proximity of the control sites to the treatment sites. The use of v-notched lobsters as a proxy for recapture rates resulted in a possible recapture rate of 3.2%, with the caveat that commercial fishers in the area also v-notch lobsters. 0000004656 00000 n Learn more about our offshore wind farms in development: Hornsea Three Hornsea Four trailer <]/Prev 488300>> startxref 0 %%EOF 106 0 obj <>stream 0000001462 00000 n Huntress preventing deployment for data collection. There are potential gradient effects at specific ranges from the infrastructure that were not captured within this study but alternative sampling at different scales and resolutions may capture these effects. Westermost Rough is capable of generating up to 210 megawatts (MW) of electricity - enough to meet the annual electricity demands of well over 150,000 UK homes. This can form ideal habitat for crustaceans (Krone et al., 2017) and has been predicted to increase diversity associated with OWF by up to 55% (Raoux et al., 2017). 0000327014 00000 n Opening in 2015, the offshore wind farm comprises of 35 6MW wind turbines and produces enough electricity to power 180,000 UK homes annually. 0000004474 00000 n [28] The first foundation pile was installed in February 2014. Grading system used to determine condition of shellfish during WMR monitoring survey. [15][16] The cable landing point is to be near Tunstall, East Riding of Yorkshire, with a national grid connection made via the buried cables to a new substation at Salt End. The differences observed are likely to be due to changes in fishing practices or natural variation causing differences in size distribution between the baseline in 2013 and the final year post construction survey in 2019. The wind farms original maintenance base and building were up for a national building award in 2015. The pre-construction year of 2013 had the greatest number of survey days and 2017 the lowest (Table 1). The specifics of the survey, such as gear type, immersion period, deployment protocol and bait used were all designed to emulate the fishing practices currently used by the fishing industry. [38], In 2017, DONG Energy rebranded themselves as rsted as the acronym for DONG Energy - Danish Oil & Natural Gas - was seen as inappropriate for a company which had divested its entire oil and gas operations and was building an energy portfolio that was approaching 100% renewable.[39]. In the pre-construction survey (2013) there was a greater proportion of lobsters of a larger size (>100mm CL) than the subsequent post construction surveys within each of the four sites (Figure 2). The wind farm site is 8 km away from Withernsea in the East Riding of Yorkshire, a center for town activity amongst the villages on the Holderness coast. This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (, A Bayesian inverse approach to identify and quantify organisms from fisheries acoustic data, Individual-based model simulations indicate a non-linear catch equationof drifting Fish Aggregating Device-associated tuna, Seaweed forests are carbon sinks that may help mitigate CO, Spatial distributional shifts and associated body condition changes of haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) following population expansion, Characterizing coastal cod vocalization using a towed hydrophone array, About the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea, http://cran.r-project.org/package=lme4%5Cnhttp://www.jstatsoft.org/index.php/jss/article/view/v067i01/v67i01.pdf, https://www.boem.gov/renewable-energy/lease-and-grant-information, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/catching-or-landing-of-berried-lobsters-and-crawfish-in-england/catching-or-landing-of-berried-lobsters-and-crawfish-in-england, http://www.eib.org/infocentre/register/all/53897501.pdf, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32018L2001&from=EN, http://socserv.socsci.mcmaster.ca/jfox/Books/Companion, https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/monthly-sea-fisheries-statistics-december-2019, https://hornseaprojectone.co.uk/about-the-project#0, https://academic.oup.com/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model, Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic, Healthy specimen, no physical impairments or signs of disease, Missing pereopods but not chellipeds, no visible signs of disease, Missing chellipeds and possibly pereopods, no visible signs of disease, Visible signs of disease but no physical impairments (e.g. GeoSea was awarded the contract to install the mono-pile foundations for the wind turbines. Stay up to date on the latest Grow West content through our feature articles and quarterly newsletter, Growing Together. The project has 35 turbines installed on the site. Environmental sustainability related Private equity deal activity in the power industry decreased by 26% in Q1 2023, Oils and coolants: high-performance products for minings unique challenges. Read more about the latest activities for these projects. The Westermost Rough Offshore Wind Farm is one of the Round 2 projects and is a wholly (100%) owned subsidiary of DONG Energy. > 1km and < 50m). The submarine and extra high-voltage cables for the Westermost Rough wind farm were supplied by LS Cable and System. B., Wilhelmsson D. Linnane A., Ball B., Mercer J. P., Browne R., Van Der Meeren G., Ringvold H., Bannister C. et al. [17], The project was the first commercial use of gearless 6MW Siemens Wind turbines;[18][19] 35 turbines were to be installed, giving a capacity of 210MW. [29] In early 2014 residents of Withernsea and the nearby area reported noise and vibration disturbance during the night time, attributed to piling at the wind farm site; by April 2014 an investigation by the Marine Management Organisation had found evidence of noise, but the results were not conclusive enough for it to act on. Siemens developed and constructed all the turbines. The observed short-term increase in LPUE associated with the windfarm closure effect observed in 2015 (Figure 4) was not highlighted during the analysis, this peak was during the construction period and was not subsequently observed during the 2017 and 2019 surveys. The blade length of the turbines is 75m, which is considered to be the worlds longest. As part of the WInd PArk Far Field (WIPAFF) project (Platis et al., 2020), several measurements were taken around wind farms in the German Bight area (Figure 2). v .GX 0000003027 00000 n Each sampling occasion within a year was given a number and defined as Haul within the model and applied as a random intercept accounting for the catch probability of lobsters varying from one haul to another on a temporal scale. History [ edit] 0000002551 00000 n Commercial fisheries are often excluded from OWFs during many stages of the construction phase because of their incompatibility with pre-construction (e.g. The lack of difference in size distribution and catch rates between the windfarm or export cable and associated controls indicate that the annual variation observed can be attributed to natural variation as opposed to the construction and operational phases of the windfarm. In the windfarm site the greatest density of larger lobsters (> MLS of 87mm CL) was observed in 2015. Descriptive statistics of surveys completed at the Westermost Rough offshore wind farm and associated export cable between 2013 and 2019. Whilst effects were observed during the construction phase, these tended to be positive results to size structure and LPUE of lobsters in the windfarm site likely the result of exclusion of fishing effort due to safety concerns. The survey design reflected the before/after, control/impact (BACI) approach as recommended by Lindeboom etal. [25]) was used to measure high-density wind details over the large wind farm area, with the experiment supported by the Carbon Trust organisation. The east coast hub at the Grimsby Royal dock is currently the most extensive operations and maintenance base for wind farms worldwide. \end{equation*}$$, Growth, reproductive cycle, and movement of berried European lobsters (Homarus gammarus) in a local stock off southwestern Norway, The potential of offshore windfarms to act as marine protected areas a systematic review of current evidence, The effect of cover on in situ predation in early benthic phase european lobster, Enhancing lobster stocks: a review of recent European methods results and future prospects, Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4, Effects of a 5-year trawling ban on the local benthic community in a wind farm in the Dutch coastal zone. All catch was recorded, and no sub-sampling was conducted throughout the entire survey. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of International Council for the Exploration of the Sea. Offshore construction for the wind power project began in January 2014 and commercial operations began in July 2015. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. The Ferndale Substation will feed it into the national grid. All lobsters sampled from both pot types (coarse and fine mesh) were aggregated for each string for analyses generating a single length frequency distribution. Barplots of the catch per unit of effort and landings per unit of effort of lobsters sampled at the wind farm and associated control site (top plots) and export cable and associated control site (bottom plots) across the four survey years (2013,15,17, & 19). It became operational in May 2015. This is intended to protect the marked lobster from exploitation until the notch has grown out, estimated at approximately two years. We were contracted to support Technip Offshore Wind Ltd (TOWL) in the installation of inter-array cables for the Westermost Rough development, located 8km off the Yorkshire coast. A wind farm in the North Sea, Westermost Rough wind farm. Subsequent post-construction surveys have highlighted a return to trends that were observed in the pre-construction survey, indicating similar size structure and LPUE but increased CPUE of lobsters. The first mono-pile for the Westernmost Rough wind farm was installed in January 2014. Credit: DONG Energy. Here at Grow West, we understand that California agriculture is complex. This collaborative research could not have been conducted without full engagement from both industries, we would also like to thank Hywel Roberts and Courtney French for supporting the research and the ongoing co-existence of the two industries. Inference from the plots derived from GLMM highlighted that in the pre-construction survey in 2013, as expected, there were no differences in the proportion of lobsters retained across the size range between the windfarm and associated control. A 50-member team monitored the wind farm construction from the operation centre being built at Fish Dock, Grimsby. In contrast, the LS cable and system were responsible for delivering the extra-high voltage and submarine cables. The vertical dashed line represents the minimum landing size of 87mm carapace length of the lobsters within the fishery. It became operational in May 2015. Westermost Rough is an important project, as it contributes to the UKs goal of installing 33GW of wind power by 2020. [30] Foundation installation was completed by May 2014,[31] and the offshore substation installed by June 2014. This is an excellent opportunity for a recent graduate or an individual with some prior accounting experience who is looking to develop their career in the field. View all newsletters from across the GlobalData Media network. The construction will represent a total investment of approximately EUR 1 billion including the construction of the transmission assets. 0000013210 00000 n 2 Min Read OSLO (Reuters) - Britain's Green Investment Group (GIG), a Macquarie Group MQG.AX unit, said on Tuesday it acquired a 25-percent interest in the Westermost Rough offshore wind. Dong Energy (50%), Marubeni Corporation (25%), UK Green Investment Bank (25%). Namely, Lincs, Race Bank, Gunfleet Sands, and Westermost Rough. The final year post-construction survey in 2019 followed the same trend as the pre-construction survey, indicating the size distribution of lobsters has not been affected by the operational phase of the windfarm. [34] Its levelised cost has been estimated at 121/MWh. The project was executed without a single Lost Time Injury (LTI). B., Tetreault I., Gaines S. D., Nisbet R. M. Krone R., Dederer G., Kanstinger P., Krmer P., Schneider C., Schmalenbach I. Lindeboom H., Degraer S., Dannheim J., Gill A. It was not possible to use identical positions at every deployment due to commercial fishing effort in the area and requirements of the developer during construction and maintenance periods. Westermost Rough Offshore Wind Farm is sited within one of the most productive lobster fishing grounds in Europe and is located 8km off the Holderness coastline in Yorkshire. This paired-series approach was taken to assess the effects of the development focusing on a paired treatment (i.e. How robust cables and connectors are vital for oil & gas operations, Cables for PV Installations in Sustainable Buildings, Small transformers and inductors for the power industry, Cable and connector suppliers for the power industry, Kusile Power Station Project, South Africa, Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant, Tamil Nadu, India.

Why Did The Blood Stop Flowing, Irish Girl Band The Corrs, I'm Jealous Of My Boyfriend's Girl Best Friend, I Have A Crush On An Older Woman, What Percent Of Crimes Are Solved By Forensic Science, Articles W